Why Is “Mary, Did You Know?” a Bad Song?
As a lover of Christmas music, I’ve always been intrigued by the polarizing reactions to the song “Mary, Did You Know?” While some find its lyrics comforting and inspiring, others dismiss it as mawkish and theologically flawed. In this article, I aim to analyze the song’s lyrics and explore the diverse perspectives on its merits and drawbacks.
A Closer Examination of the Lyrics
“Mary, Did You Know?” was written in 1991 by Mark Lowry and Buddy Greene. The song’s lyrics depict an angel questioning Mary about her understanding of Jesus’ divine nature. The angel asks a series of probing questions, such as:
- “Did you know that your Baby Boy has walked where angels tread?”
- “Do you know that your Baby Boy is Lord of all creation?”
- “Do you know that your Baby Boy is heaven’s perfect Lamb?”
The song’s refrain emphasizes Mary’s unfathomable task of raising and nurturing the Son of God:
Mary, did you know that your Baby Boy would one day rule the nations?
Mary, did you know that your Baby Boy would one day save the nations?
Theological Concerns
Critics of “Mary, Did You Know?” argue that its lyrics are theologically unsound. They point out that Mary, as a devout Jew, would have been familiar with the messianic prophecies and would have understood Jesus’ divine mission. Therefore, the angel’s questions seem unnecessary and even disrespectful.
Additionally, some theologians question the song’s portrayal of Jesus as a remote and distant figure. The lyrics emphasize his power and majesty but seem to downplay his humanity and compassion. This raises concerns about creating an overly idealized image of Christ that overlooks his humble beginnings and identification with the suffering.
Cultural and Emotional Resonance
Despite its theological shortcomings, “Mary, Did You Know?” has resonated with many listeners for its emotional and cultural significance. The song’s simple melody and straightforward lyrics evoke a sense of wonder and awe. It appeals to believers and non-believers alike, reminding listeners of the transformative message of Christmas.
Furthermore, the song’s popularity has been fueled by its widespread use in Christmas concerts, church services, and family gatherings. Its familiarity and emotional associations have made it a beloved holiday classic for many.
Tips for Understanding and Appreciating “Mary, Did You Know?”
If you’re unsure how to respond to “Mary, Did You Know?,” consider the following tips:
- Recognize its cultural and emotional significance: Accept that the song has a special place in the hearts of many, even if you don’t share their enthusiasm.
- Focus on its message of hope and faith: While the lyrics may not be theologically perfect, the song can still evoke a sense of wonder and gratitude.
- Consider its historical context: The song was written in a specific time and place and reflects the beliefs and values of its era.
FAQ on “Mary, Did You Know?”
Q: Is “Mary, Did You Know?” considered a Christmas carol?
A: While the song is often associated with Christmas, it is not a traditional Christmas carol. It was originally written for a contemporary Christian music album.
Q: Who is the angel in the song?
A: The song’s lyrics do not explicitly identify the angel, but it is commonly assumed to be the angel Gabriel, who appeared to Mary at the Annunciation.
Q: What is the significance of the phrase “heaven’s perfect Lamb”?
A: In Christian theology, Jesus is often referred to as the Lamb of God, a symbol of his sacrificial death and resurrection. The phrase “heaven’s perfect Lamb” highlights his sinless nature and divine destiny.
Conclusion
“Mary, Did You Know?” is a controversial song that has sparked passionate debates among listeners. While its theological flaws may detract from its credibility for some, its cultural and emotional resonance ensure its enduring popularity. Ultimately, whether you find the song inspiring or offensive is a matter of personal taste and belief.
However, I encourage you to approach the topic with an open mind and a willingness to engage in respectful dialogue. Let the song serve as a catalyst for further reflection on the mystery and wonder of Christmas.
